The paper bag in AIM 8−1−3, and what to do in the airplane
AIM 8−1−3 still tells a hyperventilating pilot to breathe into a paper bag, while current medical guidance has moved on from that line and AC 61-107B already treats the episode with oxygen, slower breathing, and descent.
FlyCurrent's CFI page on hyperventilation (ACS element AI.II.A.K1b) quotes the AIM word for word, and that includes the paper-bag sentence. Those pages quote FAA text as written, and I left that line alone on purpose. This piece is where I explain, as a physician and a pilot, why I would not use the bag in an airplane and what I would do instead.
What the FAA says
AIM 8−1−3b says the symptoms of hyperventilation "subside within a few minutes after the rate and depth of breathing are consciously brought back under control," and then adds: "The buildup of carbon dioxide in the body can be hastened by controlled breathing in and out of a paper bag held over the nose and mouth." (AIM 8−1−3b)
On page 17-5 the PHAK pairs a slower rate with "breathing into a paper bag or talking aloud helps to overcome hyperventilation." (PHAK, FAA-H-8083-25C, p. 17-5) The 2024 Balloon Flying Handbook repeats that wording on page 9-3. (Balloon Flying Handbook, FAA-H-8083-11B, p. 9-3) AIM Change 3 (effective July 9, 2026) left 8−1−3 unchanged.
AIM 8−1−3c says the early symptoms of hyperventilation and hypoxia are similar and that the two can occur at the same time. If you are on oxygen, "the oxygen regulator should immediately be set to deliver 100 percent oxygen, and then the system checked to assure that it has been functioning effectively before giving attention to rate and depth of breathing." (AIM 8−1−3c)
AC 61-107B, status Active, says to treat hypoxia and hyperventilation together with 100 percent oxygen, slower breathing, an equipment check, and descent. It says nothing about a bag. (AC 61-107B) The 2024 Glider Flying Handbook says to slow the breathing or talk aloud, and does not mention a bag. (Glider Flying Handbook, FAA-H-8083-13B, ch. 13) The FAA's pilot hypoxia page says to slow your breathing on purpose, again with no bag. (FAA hypoxia page)
So the FAA's own texts disagree with each other. The newer, aviation-specific ones leave the bag out, and current medical guidance has moved past it too.
What current medical guidance says
ANZCOR Guideline 9.2.8, approved March 2023, "strongly recommends against using any form of rebreathing (e.g. paper bag) for the management of hyperventilation." Rebreathing "can result in critically low oxygen levels and may cause harm." (ANZCOR Guideline 9.2.8) The British Thoracic Society's 2017 emergency oxygen guideline says: "Rebreathing from a paper bag can be dangerous and is NOT advised as a treatment for hyperventilation." (BTS, 2017)
Both cite the same paper, Callaham (1989). He reported three deaths when the bag was used on patients who were actually hypoxemic or had myocardial ischemia. He then measured oxygen inside the bag in 20 healthy volunteers: a mean maximal drop of 26 mm Hg, up to 42 mm Hg. Those drops were measured in the bag gas, what you breathe in, not in arterial blood. Prehospital use, he concluded, "should be abandoned." (Callaham, 1989)
The benefit is also smaller than it looks. In volunteers, van den Hout (1988) found that how fast symptoms cleared depended partly on expectation. Symptoms cleared sooner with the bag when the subjects knew the rationale, and not significantly sooner when they thought both trials were rebreathing. (van den Hout, 1988)
The core problem is misdiagnosis. The bag is only "safe" if you already know the cause is anxiety and oxygen is fine. ANZCOR says not to assume hyperventilation is psychological. Serious conditions can make a person anxious, and missing them is more dangerous than overtreating a panic attack. Callaham wrote that paper bag rebreathing should never be given unless myocardial ischemia can be ruled out and oxygenation has been directly measured, and that those conditions are impossible outside a hospital. (Callaham, 1989) A cockpit is about as far outside a hospital as you can get.
Why the cockpit makes it worse
The percentage of oxygen stays the same as you climb. The partial pressure falls with atmospheric pressure. (PHAK, FAA-H-8083-25C, p. 17-3) At 18,000 feet MSL "you have half the sea level air pressure; hence, only half the oxygen." (FAA hypoxia brochure)
A bag lowers the oxygen in each breath further. Callaham measured that drop on the ground, starting from room air. Nobody I can find has measured it at altitude. As a physician I read the two findings as stacking: altitude has already lowered the oxygen pressure, and the bag then lowers the oxygen in what you breathe back in. That is my reasoning from the two findings, not a measured result.
Hypoxia and hyperventilation feel alike and can happen together. (AIM 8−1−3c) AC 61-107B notes that hyperventilation is an early response to hypoxia at altitude, which makes them harder to separate. The early symptoms overlap: lightheadedness, tingling, visual changes. You cannot tell which one you have by how it feels, and you are also the person flying the airplane. (AC 61-107B; PHAK, p. 17-5)
Carbon monoxide from the exhaust can produce hypoxia effects too. AIM 8−1−4a says carbon monoxide "can significantly reduce the ability of the blood to carry oxygen. Consequently, effects of hypoxia occur." (AIM 8−1−4a)
What to do instead
Treat it as hypoxia until proven otherwise.
If you are on oxygen, set 100 percent (or the system's maximum) and check that it is working before you attend to rate and depth. (AIM 8−1−3c; AC 61-107B) If oxygen is available and you are not using it, put it on. The circular says to "breathe 100 percent oxygen; it will not worsen hyperventilation." (AC 61-107B)
Descend, when it is safe, to an altitude where hypoxia is unlikely. The FAA hypoxia page says below 10,000 feet. (AC 61-107B; FAA hypoxia page)
Slow the breathing on purpose. Talking aloud helps. (PHAK, FAA-H-8083-25C, p. 17-5; Glider Flying Handbook, ch. 13) When a panic attack is the likely cause, ANZCOR says: "Encourage the person to establish slow and regular breathing." (ANZCOR Guideline 9.2.8)
Fly the airplane, and tell ATC or a passenger what is going on.
Leave the bag in the seat pocket.
If the symptoms do not clear once breathing slows, or if there is chest pain, treat it as a medical emergency and get on the ground. ANZCOR, writing for first aid on the ground, says "if there is any doubt at all about whether the person's abnormal breathing is caused by hyperventilation or another problem, send for an ambulance." (ANZCOR Guideline 9.2.8) Heart attack is on that guideline's list of causes. The AIM says symptoms subside within a few minutes once breathing is under control. If they don't, stop waiting for them to.
For CFIs and applicants
An applicant should know what the AIM says, paper bag included. They should also be able to explain why the answer in the airplane is oxygen, descent, and slow breathing, and why the bag is the one piece of that paragraph to leave out. Teaching the why is the point. The K1b page links here for that reason.
Stephen J. Ronan, MD, is a board-certified plastic surgeon, a pilot, and the founder of FlyCurrent. Sources are listed below. This is education for pilots and instructors, not individual medical advice.